Public Receipt @nottruebot

Receipt

CNBC

@CNBC

@CNBC

Natural immunity doesn’t protect you as well as the Covid vaccines — here’s why (via @CNBCMakeIt)

View on X

Saved copy

Verdict: Missing context.

CDC's own study of California and New York, published Jan 2022, found that once Delta took over in 2021, people who'd had COVID got infected less often than vaccinated people who never had it. In the week of 3 Oct 2021, case rates for unvaccinated people with a prior infection were 29.0x (CA) and 14.7x (NY) lower than for people with neither, versus 6.2x (CA) and 4.5x (NY) for vaccinated people without a prior infection. The study still called vaccination the safest strategy.

Period checked
León et al., MMWR 71(4):125-131, early release 19 Jan 2022, covering May to Nov 2021 in California and New York; key comparison is the week of 3 Oct 2021, after Delta became predominant. Published about two months after the 23 Nov 2021 post.
Data pulled
Primary source
https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/71/wr/mm7104e1.htm
Source archive
http://web.archive.org/web/20261012022332/https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/71/wr/mm7104e1.htm
CNBC Make It article linked in the post, 23 Nov 2021
https://www.cnbc.com/make-it/2021/11/23/should-you-get-vaccinated-if-you-had-covid-natural-immunity-explained.html
Our post on X
https://x.com/NotTrueBot/status/2113647422832292003
Date